This is a list of the top five TV episodes we all wished for that never came to fruition.
- Judge Wapner has a heart attack: This episode of the People’s Court start’s normally. The plaintiff is George Adamson, a Motel 6 owner in Albuquerque. The defendant is a cat owner from Kazakhstan who was a customer of Adamson’s. The cat was allegedly having digestive issues, and Adamson wants the defendant to pay to have the carpet shampooed, curtains replaced, and walls repainted. The defendant is counter suing, claiming emotional damage to his cat that now is taking antidepressants. The case proceeds as normal until Judge Wapner begins to have a heated exchange with the defendant. Suddenly, Wapner jumps up, yelps, and grasps his chest. He staggers a few steps and takes a fantastic spill into the witness box, destroying it in the process. Rusty the Bailiff kneels at Wapner’s side to check on him. Rusty then draws his side arm and begins firing into the air, stating repeatedly that everyone must leave the courtroom. We then cut to Doug Llewelyn, standing outside the courtroom. Llewelyn calmly interviews both the plaintiff and the defendant, asking them for a response to the outcome of the trial. Wapner later recovers after undergoing quadruple bypass surgery to continue the show for many more years.
- Screech Almost Wins the Talent Show: In this episode of Saved by the Bell, Bayside High School is having a talent show. Along with many other students, the main characters all eagerly sign up promising each other that they will not let the competition interfere with their friendships. As the day of the competition nears, however, the pressure to win is clearly grating on everyone; and Zach, Lisa, Kelly, Slater, Jesse, and Screech are barely speaking to one another. By the day of the competition, the viewers are meant to think that the gang may split up for good. The actual competition is set up so that in each round, the contestants who get the most cheers from the crowd get to advance. The final round pits Screech against his ‘former’ best friend, Zach Morris. Mr. Belding announces that for the final round, there will be a special guest judge. A curtain on the stage rises, revealing Judge Wapner sitting at his bench. Screech and Zach perform their respective acts. It is clear that Wapner prefers Screech’s performance. After deliberating for a few moments, Wapner prepares to deliver his verdict. Suddenly, Wapner jumps up, yelps, and grasps his chest. He staggers a few steps and takes a fantastic spill into some band equipment. Rusty the Janitor kneels at Wapner’s side to check on him. Rusty then draws his side arm and begins firing into the air, stating repeatedly that everyone must leave the auditorium. We then cut to Doug Llewelyn, who calmly interviews Mr. Belding in his office. The event helps the gang realize how much more important their friendship is than winning some competition.
- Donna Martin’s New Boyfriend: In this episode of Beverly Hills 90210, Tori Spelling’s character, Donna Martin, starts to secretly date a new beau without telling any of her friends. Soon, the others become curious and pester her about it until she agrees to reveal his identity the following night at dinner. The next evening, the gang is at an Italian restaurant. Donna Martin walks in and dramatically reveals that her boyfriend is none other than Judge Joseph Wapner. Everyone is initially shocked, but the dinner ends up going very well. Judge Wapner is fun to be around and has many great stories tell about his years as a judge. The teens do worry, though, because he has ordered a great deal of fried foods with cream sauces and a double serving of Chocolate Fudge Explosion Death with a triple helping of ice cream. After a commercial break, we join Donna Martin and Judge Wapner at Wapner’s retirement condominium. They are passionately kissing and embracing. Suddenly, Wapner jumps draws back and yelp, grasping his chest. He staggers a few steps back before taking a fantastic spill through an arrangement of expensive vases that have been placed precariously. Rusty, the condo maintenance man rushes in and kneels at Wapner’s side to check on him. Rusty then draws his side arm and begins firing into the air, stating repeatedly that Donna must leave the condominium. The show then cuts to Doug Llewelyn, who calmly interviews a confused Brandon Walsh (Jason Priestly) about the preceding events. The show then ends in the manner which it would normally end.
- Woman Dressed as a Clown Wins One Million Dollars: In this edition of Let’s Make a Deal, Monty Hall has a female contestant on stage who is dressed as a clown. She has thus far accumulated an old rusty bicycle, five hundred thirteen dollars in cash, and a plastic toad. Monty shows the contestant three closed doors. She can trade in her money and tchotchkes to choose one of the doors. Behind two doors are items even more worthless than the ones she is holding, and behind the third door is something of great value. The clown-woman agonizes for a good five minutes. Finally she chooses door number two. Monty Hall confirms that she is sure of her decision. Hall proceeds to open the door. Inside is none other than Judge Wapner. He is yelping and grasping his chest. He staggers out for a few steps before taking a fantastic spill into the mystery box that the clown-woman earlier passed over. As Wapner crashes through the box, the stuffed animal booby prize inside is revealed, confirming that it was a good decision to not choose that box. The contestant looks disappointed, thinking that the ailing Wapner is her prize and worrying that she is not going to know how to take care of him. Monty Hall tells her not to fret so quickly as he strolls over to prone Wapner. Hall reaches under Wapner’s judicial robes and feels around for a few minutes. Finally, he retrieves a paper sack, which he then takes to the contestant. The sack contains one million dollars, the actual prize the contestant has won. She is ecstatic. Rusty, who is in the crowd, dressed as a bailiff, walks to the stage and kneels next to Judge Wapner to check on him. He then draws his side arm and begins shooting into the air stating repeatedly that everyone must leave the studio. The show then cuts outside to Doug Llewelyn, who calmly interviews a bewildered audience member who is dressed in a full body suit with airbrushed musculature on the outside.
- Prince Tuesday Ascends to the Throne: Mister Rogers Neighborhood has always been known for dealing with serious issues head on in a manner that is palatable to children. This episode is no different; in it, we learn that people sometimes die in horribly tragic circumstances. The most of the show proceeds normally with Mr. Rogers entering, changing clothes, and singing his song at the beginning. After talking to the children about nice ways of dealing with acrimonious situations, he goes on a filmed tour of an airplane factory. As the show nears its end, the trolley takes the viewers to the Neighborhood of Make-Believe to observe the activities of its citizens. King Friday has proclaimed this day to be the day during which citizens of the neighborhood may adjudicate disputes of less than fifty gold pieces. Unfortunately, the judge who has administrated such proceedings in the past has moved to Someplace Else. However, King Friday has brought in a temporary replacement, none other than Judge Joseph Wapner. As the judge is about to start the first proceeding, he suddenly jumps up, yelps, and grasps his chest. After staggering around for a few moments, he takes a fantastic spill, destroying a hill and the royal castle before coming to rest on top of King Friday. Rusty the puppeteer comes out and kneels next to Wapner to check on him. Rusty draws his side arm and begins firing into the air as he repeatedly states that everyone needs to leave the neighborhood. As Wapner is rushed to a hospital with Rusty at his side, King Friday is declared dead at the scene. As per the laws governing Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Prince Tuesday is immediately coronated King Tuesday XIV of Neighborhood of Make-Believe. The trolley then returns to Mister Rogers’ apartment where Doug Llewelyn calmly interviews Rogers about the preceding events. Mister Rogers explains to the viewers that life can be short and that any of them could die from a giant man in judicial robes collapsing on them at any moment. He then quickly changes into his street clothes and leaves without the usual singing and fanfare.